New York City, a place that has inspired countless songs, poems, and stories, is the subject of Sharon Van Etten's heartfelt ode, 'Seventeen.' This song, a personal reflection on the ever-evolving nature of the city and its impact on individuals, offers a unique perspective on the human experience within this iconic metropolis.
The Ever-Changing City
New York, as Joan Didion so eloquently put it, is more than just a city; it's a romantic notion, a dream. And Van Etten's song captures this sentiment beautifully. 'Seventeen' is not just about a place; it's about the passage of time and how it shapes our environments and ourselves.
As an adopted New Yorker, Van Etten's perspective is intriguing. Born in New Jersey and raised in Nashville, her move to New York in 2005 marked a significant shift in her life. The song reflects on the changes she witnessed in the city over the years, a transformation that is both fascinating and poignant.
A Personal Journey
What makes 'Seventeen' so captivating is its ability to intertwine the city's evolution with Van Etten's personal growth. The song highlights the difference in perception between youth and experience. When you're young, the closure of a shop might seem insignificant, but as time passes, you realize it's more than just a business; it's a community, a shared history, and a symbol of aspirations.
Van Etten's powerful yet fragile vocals add to the song's emotional depth. The lyrics, "Downtown harks back / Halfway up the street / I used to be free / I used to be 17," are a poignant reminder of the freedom and innocence of youth, and how it contrasts with the complexities of adulthood.
Visualizing the City
The music video, directed by Maureen Towey, is a visual masterpiece. It takes us on a journey through Van Etten's New York, showcasing places like Union Pool and Baby's All Right, which hold a special place in her heart and her musical journey. Towey's vision captures the city's beauty and its rough edges, reflecting the song's sentiment of a city that nurtures dreams while also facing challenges.
A Song of Reflection, Not Nostalgia
While 'Seventeen' is a mournful lament, it's not stuck in the past. It understands the transient nature of life and accepts change. The song's message aligns with Bob Dylan's words in 'To Ramona': "Everything passes, everything changes." It's a reminder that change is inevitable, and we must embrace it.
This song, and Van Etten's perspective, offer a refreshing take on the classic theme of New York City in music. It's a story of growth, of understanding, and of finding beauty in the ever-changing landscape of life and the city that never sleeps.
A Deeper Reflection
'Seventeen' invites us to consider our own relationships with our environments. As we grow older, do we become more attached to the places that shaped us? Or do we learn to let go and embrace the new? It's a song that sparks introspection and a deeper appreciation for the cities and communities that have impacted our lives.
In my opinion, Van Etten's 'Seventeen' is a masterpiece of modern songwriting, a perfect blend of personal narrative and universal themes. It's a song that will resonate with anyone who has ever felt the pull of a city, the nostalgia of youth, and the understanding that comes with age.
